Author: Alistair Aitken

Do Good Players Make Good Judges or Teachers? – Conclusion

Posted on      by      Leave a comment

The judging parameters for solo piping have traditionally been less regulated than those for pipe bands. (There has never been any formal criteria for solo drumming either.)  Nevertheless there are grounds for arguing that the skill requirements for adjudicating solo piping and drumming are much the same as for bands.  With bands, these basic requirements and abilities should apply to every adjudicator, irrespective of discipline, piping, drumming or ensemble.  Some…

More Do Good Players Make Good Judges or Teachers? – Conclusion

Do Good Players Make Good Teachers or Judges?

Posted on      by      3 Comments

The subjects of teaching and adjudication are never far from the surface in the piping and pipe band world. Both can attract widely differing views and can be contentious. There is no doubt that much has changed over the years in methods of teaching piping and drumming. What has certainly not changed is the need to learn properly the basic rudiments, embellishments and musical theory relevant to both musical disciplines. An article…

More Do Good Players Make Good Teachers or Judges?

History: Pipe Bands in the East of Scotland Part 4

Posted on      by      8 Comments

I am extremely grateful to reader Iain McAlister for forwarding the pictures which illustrate this article and for the information on the bands in the photographs. Of the one above, Iain writes: ‘The picture of the band in uniform is Whitrigg, unknown year, Pipe Major Elkie Clark. Kneeling front right is a very young Robert Martin, later to become P/M of Boghall.’ Iain has sent three other very interesting pictures…

More History: Pipe Bands in the East of Scotland Part 4

History: Pipe Bands in the East of Scotland Over the Years – Part 2

Posted on      by      3 Comments

The decline of the coal mining industry in Scotland between the late 1950s and 1980s resulted in the loss of most of the former colliery bands, a mainstay of competitions during their existence.  This had a significant affect on the East of Scotland which had had many colliery bands in the Lothians and Fife. Pictured above in 1974 are the former Grade 1 band, Polkemmet Colliery. To that problem we…

More History: Pipe Bands in the East of Scotland Over the Years – Part 2

History: Pipe Bands in the East of Scotland Over the Years

Posted on      by      Leave a comment

Having been a member of three East of Scotland pipe bands and involved with various others over more than 50 years I have built up some knowledge of many of them.  It would take a great deal of research to compile a detailed history, much of which might be difficult to find, so this article is more general. I apologise from the outset for anything, or any band or any…

More History: Pipe Bands in the East of Scotland Over the Years