As already mentioned the RSPBA previously undertook a number of trials of the semi-circle format in 1998. I participated in the trial at Bathgate Highland Games. As far as I am aware no advice was given to the bands about how the pipers and drummers should form up in the semi-circle, so there were wide variations which resulted in different sound projections. One band even had the drummers facing backwards…
Suggestions have been made from time to time for the circle formation to be replaced by a concert style semi-circle, the main argument being that bands would be able to face their audience. It is not a new idea as the RSPBA conducted trials of the format in 1998 but decided not to implement it at that time. I do not recall the reasons ever being made public. As always…
I had not anticipated my article on Piping Press about the recent World Pipe Band Championships would generate debate about the circle formation for competing bands. My reference to containing and balancing the sounds with the circle formation were intended merely as a reference to only one of the aspects of the original thinking when the circle formation was introduced. I also did not suggest any preference for either a…
The following offer some general observations I noted over the two days regarding the bands which played in the main arena. The four in Juvenile played their musical medleys very well and illustrated the standard of tuition in the schools they represented. It is just a pity the numbers in this grade have been in single figures in recent years. Hopefully they can be expanded as the pandemic recovery continues. …
The 2022 Worlds took place in unusually extreme heat. I listened to most of Grade 1 from the spectator stand on both days, although was forced to leave the stand mid-afternoon each day when I could tolerate the heat no longer. The seats in the main stand are not what you would ever describe as comfortable either! Perhaps it is due to my advancing years, but I cannot ever recall such…
Recent Comments