Tag: solo piping judging

Embarrassing Emails and Another Resignation at the Solo Piping Judges Association

Posted on      by     

Adjudicator Mr Barry Donaldson has circulated new information on his dispute with the Solo Piping Judges Association. It has been sent to all of its 50+ member judges.  A copy has been obtained by Piping Press. When contacted by PP, Mr Donaldson said he had given the SPJA committee every opportunity of dealing with the matter internally but, in an effort to seize the initiative, they had circulated a statement…

More Embarrassing Emails and Another Resignation at the Solo Piping Judges Association

PP Editor’s Blog: Judging/Bellows Piping/Band Re-Grades

Posted on      by     

Mr McCombie-Smith made some interesting comments yesterday regarding manufacturers and judging in the 1890s. In more modern times this is something that has been an issue, but more so in the bands. The matter was quickly sorted a few years ago when the RSPBA introduced monitoring. Any judge giving preferential treatment to bands playing his instruments could be easily identified and the matter is no longer a concern.  Unfortunately it has, indirectly, reared…

More PP Editor’s Blog: Judging/Bellows Piping/Band Re-Grades

The Quality of Solo and Band Adjudication

Posted on      by     

[wds id=”2″] Robert Wallace: This quiet period in the piping and pipe band season affords an opportunity to look back through old documents and magazines. Many’s the pleasant hour can be spent thus engaged. I thought I’d share this excerpt from the ‘Piping and Dancing’ magazine of September 1939 with our readers.  Some reflections on it tomorrow, time permitting. There are wonderful film clips of Cowal in the 30s on British…

More The Quality of Solo and Band Adjudication