Category: Results

The Basics of Pipe Band Ensemble Judging

Posted on      by      2 Comments

The word ensemble, translated from the French, means ‘together.’ How together are the various sections of the pipe band: the pipers, the side drummers and the bass and tenors? In current competition format, how clearly defined are the roles of the piping, drumming, and ensemble judges in measuring this togetherness? By Alan Jones Who measures it within a given section and between the various sections? Is there any overlap of…

More The Basics of Pipe Band Ensemble Judging

Scots Guards KO/ Graeme Johnston/ China Contest

Posted on      by      Leave a comment

The Army’s Scott McCaskill (pictured) won through to the next round of the Scots Guards KO contest held yesterday at the SG Club, Haymarket, Edinburgh. The large crowd narrowly voted Scott through against his opponent Ross Conner, Campbeltown. Graeme Johnston Contest The West of Scotland Branch of the RSPBA attracted a large entry to their annual juvenile contest held in memory of pipe band stalwart Graeme Johnston. The event was…

More Scots Guards KO/ Graeme Johnston/ China Contest

Germany’s Northern Winter Competition Continues to Grow in Stature

Posted on      by      Leave a comment

One hundred and forty pipers and drummers converged on the German city of Bremen at the weekend for the Northern Winter Competition, writes the Editor. Organised by the Bagpipe Association of Germany, it was a triumph of efficiency and balance: camaraderie, fierce competition in equal measure. Piping judges were myself, Barry Donaldson, Peter Hunt and Allan MacDonald. There were solos at every level and quintets for bands. This last worked…

More Germany’s Northern Winter Competition Continues to Grow in Stature

Responses to ‘Judge’s Dilemma at Glenfiddich’ article

Posted on      by      Leave a comment

Neil Mulvie: ‘I find it difficult not to be impressed by the approach to judging and scrutiny that Norman [Matheson] describes in his letter to Andrew Wright. And I am certain that Andrew would have totally agreed with Norman’s views. ‘Andrew often quoted Andrew MacNeill, saying that he was more comfortable awarding a prize to the piper, ‘who went off the tune rather than one who was never on it…

More Responses to ‘Judge’s Dilemma at Glenfiddich’ article

History: Judge’s Dilemma at Glenfiddich Competition

Posted on      by      Leave a comment

In 1993 there was a boycott of the main piping competitions by a large tranche of the competing piping community. They had been driven to take such drastic action by what they perceived as the poor standard of judging then extant. The boycott led to the formation of the Joint Committee for Judging representing all interested parties, pipers, promoters, judges. It was to oversee matters of dispute. Andrew Wright was…

More History: Judge’s Dilemma at Glenfiddich Competition