‘Talk Piobaireachd – Magic of the MacCrimmons’

The Piobaireachd Society’s first ‘Talk Piobaireachd’ session of the 26/27 winter was held last night to great acclaim. There were just under 90 attendees at the online talk given by multi-award winning piper Jack Lee, British Columbia.

The title for the series is the ‘Magic of the MacCrimmons’ and each session will examine two of the legendary family’s magnificent works.

By the Editor

Jack’s tunes last night were Mrs MacLeod of Talisker’s Salute and the MacLeod’s Salute. The audience learned that the first had been written by Donald Ruadh MacCrimmon, one of the last of its composers. Donald Ruadh had seen service in the British Army in North America during the Wars of Independence.

Jack pointed out the phrasing and subtleties necessary to make the most of ‘Talisker’ (PS Bk.11, p336). Using the practice chanter he carefully guided us through his preferred way of the tune. Then this master at work played the urlar on the full bagpipe.

Thus, thanks to modern technology, those of us in the UK were taken to Jack’s piping room thousands of miles away, back to the continent where the composer had possibly found inspiration for the tune in the first place (see photo above).

‘Talisker’ was a lengthy tune with triplet, taorluath and crunluath variations, singling and doubling – and an a mach was a must for anyone playing it in competition.


MacRaeBanner ’19

Jack then turned his attention to his second piece, MacLeod’s Salute (PS Bk. 12, p372). This was one of a trilogy of tunes marking the bloody, late 16th century feud between the MacLeods and the MacDonalds.

Bridget MacKenzie’s ‘Piping Traditions of Skye’ tells us that it worsened after Margaret, a sister of Chief Rory Mor MacLeod, was offered in marriage to Donald Gorm, Chief of the MacDonalds. This attempt at reconciliation of the decades-long feud failed.

After a year, the poor woman, who had only one eye, was returned to her brother by Donald Gorm ‘in the most insulting way he could devise, mounted on a one-eyed horse, escorted by a one-eyed groom, and a one-eyed dog.’

Much blood was spilled before King James VI intervened and a settlement agreed. Donald Mor MacCrimmon produced three tunes in honour of the peace, the MacDonald’s Salute, MacLeod’s Controversy and the MacLeod’s Salute.

All are characterised by the famous ‘Donald Mor rundown’, the rapid descent from E to low G. Jack pointed out different ways of handling this – one with a slight pause on the low A – but he felt those who played the long B instead of the run down were missing out on a dramatic musical effect.

Again he demonstrated the tune on the practice chanter, praised the musical turns in the dithis, and showed how the a mach – vital in this tune in its taorluath and crunluath forms – should be fingered. It was a stunning piece of music, only its length, precluding it from inclusion in the lists at the top events.

To close, Jack fielded questions and we signed off the better for an hour in his company.

  • ‘Talk Piobaireachd’ is open to all members of the Piobaireachd Society. The talks are recorded and can be accessed on the Society’s website. If you are not a member you can join here. The next TP is on December 16 when Mike Cusack will discuss Rory MacLeod’s Lament and I Gave a Kiss to the King’s Hand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *