Category: Comment

Revisionist Piobaireachd and the Tradition as it Has Come Down to Us

Posted on      by     

David Hester of the Alt Pibroch website has been in touch following my article on judging and subsequent comments on Donald MacDonald. David: Two quick questions, just for the purpose of me gaining a bit of insight and better sensitivity to the idiom: 1) What is particularly poor about the fare of the MacDonald book and manuscript?  Is it missing something, for example?  Are the pibrochs chosen too massive?  Some…

More Revisionist Piobaireachd and the Tradition as it Has Come Down to Us

Tobermory Games: Full Results and Critique of the Ceol Mor

Posted on      by     

A warm, sunny day and a high standard of play. Apart from the solo piping boards, the large crowd was entertained royally by Oban High School Pipe Band under P/M Angus MacColl Snr. and the Mull & Iona Pipe Band under P/M Neil MacCallum. Angus is pictured above on his way to glory in the ceol mor. Piobaireachd (three tunes asked for and given and selected tune given at the…

More Tobermory Games: Full Results and Critique of the Ceol Mor

Thoughts on James Campbell’s Letters regarding ‘Masters of Piobaireachd’

Posted on      by     

The Masters of Piobaireachd series comprising 10 CDs was an initiative of Norman Matheson and Robert Wallace. As each CD was released, Norman sent a copy to the late James Campbell who responded with letters of analytical content, extracts of which appeared in Piping Press from March 2015. For those pipers who have the CD collection, the letters are of interest, and to retain them along with their collection would be…

More Thoughts on James Campbell’s Letters regarding ‘Masters of Piobaireachd’

Minor Contests Poll: Overwhelming Call for Support / Roseneath Draw

Posted on      by     

The vast majority of the hundreds of readers who responded to our poll on minor band contests are concerned about the lack of support these events are getting. And they are calling on Grade 1 and Grade 2 bands – and the RSPBA – to do more to help. In answer to our question ‘Do Grade 1 & 2 bands have a duty to support the smaller competitions and Highland…

More Minor Contests Poll: Overwhelming Call for Support / Roseneath Draw

PP Editor’s Blog: Paisley Contest/ Ardrossan/ Antigonish

Posted on      by     

I see that Scottish Power pipe band have entered next Saturday’s minor contest at Paisley (July 23rd). Well done to the band for that. Their presence will inspire the smaller bands and give them a chance to hear one of the best in the world. It will be a good marketing opportunity for the Power’s sponsors too and help ensure continued funding – very important.  The contest starts at 10.30am…

More PP Editor’s Blog: Paisley Contest/ Ardrossan/ Antigonish