RSPBA Calls for Band Practice Ban to be Lifted

Chairman of the RSPBA, John Hughes, has asked all band secretaries to write to their MSPs urging them get Scotland’s devolved administration to loosen the rules governing musicians practising together.

Practices for all woodwind and brass instruments are allowed in England, Wales and Northern Ireland but not Scotland.

The concern is that the pipes could blast an aerosol of infectious particles into the air. Recent studies have shown that this is not the case with only flute ‘blow past’ travelling 75cms from the player’s mouth.



And while all other parts of the United Kingdom now allow bands to perform outdoors at a safe social distance, a strict clampdown remains in force north of the Border. The ban is also serously affecting piping tutiton in schools with teachers of the relevant instruments restricted to onlne instructions and exams.

Now Mr Hughes, has written to all band secretaries asking them to contact their local MSPs to demand a rethink. He said: ‘At the moment, Scotland is the only country in the UK not allowing even outdoor playing to take place so long as local guidance is followed. 

‘Meeting people outdoors with social distancing is limited to 15 people from no more than five households, and eight people from no more than three households indoors.

‘Pipe bands vary in membership size and these rules just don’t allow any meaningful practice either outdoor or indoor. Furthermore, the guidance doesn’t allow the playing of instruments, only meeting in person.

‘In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, you can have up to 30 people with no limit on the number of households playing socially distant. So our Northern Irish, English and Welsh pipe bands can all get an outdoor practice but we cannot.

‘We’d ask that this is reviewed on an urgent basis to allow Scottish pipe bands to practice outdoors initially and indoors in the near future.’

Mr Hughes has written to National Clinical Director Jason Leitch and asked for scientific evidence that bagpipes are a Covid-19 health hazard but is awaiting a response.

He added: ‘We’re worried that if we can’t get this changed, we’ll have no winter practice and very few bands ready to come out next summer for events, if they can go ahead.’


4 thoughts on “RSPBA Calls for Band Practice Ban to be Lifted

  1. Read the post. My issue with this, and actually apologies again, because I read the Daily Record article before I read yours.
    The reality is there is NO Band Practice ban. The headline in both this but more so the Record is very misleading. It gives (certainly to me) the impression that the Scottish Government has expressly forbidden Band Practises. Band Practices ARE taking place outdoors. I actually don’t think that the RSPBA needs to get involved in this at all. The guidance re numbers gathering has been set down by the Gov, why does the RSPBA need to ask for further guidance? There’s a quote from Mr Hughes there saying that Scotland isn’t allowing outdoor playing, thats simply not true. Teaching IS taking place in Glasgow schools at least. There may well be a cap on numbers practicing indoors, but thats the drill for everything. To bleat that bands are being restricted is misleading, and incorrect. I have no doubt that the Record article is politically biaised, I don’t of course think that this is. Lastly… In other countries in the UK… numbers up to 30 can meet. As reported above. It’s fortunate then, that there are no large G1 bands south of the border, as they wouldnt be able to practice either.

  2. Robert, would it be possible to have sight of this “practice ban”
    Unless I’ve missed it, I’m not aware that there has been one.
    No hearsay please… actually documentary evidence?
    Thanks.

    Neil

    1. From reading his comments I think John Hughes is interpreting the numbers allowed to meet together at any one time as being tantamount to a ban. Read the recent post on the RSPBA website. Hopefully he will respond to your query in more detail. You should know by now that Piping Press does not deal in hearsay unless stated so no pejorative inferences please Neil. RW

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.